Anyone who has been playing World of Warcraft for a while knows the principle: As soon as a new expansion or raid is released, the first Best-in-Slot lists (BiS) are published. They show which weapons, armor pieces, and trinkets are theoretically the best for your class.
But Blizzard increasingly wants to move away from this principle in World of Warcraft: Forever .
In the current WoW Forever podcast, Senior Game Designer Aidan “Zirene” Moon explained that he fundamentally questions the idea of a single optimal set of gear for each class.
In his opinion, a role-playing game should not boil down to every player working through the same list. Instead, the choice of equipment should depend more on the opponent faced and the challenges a fight presents.
What does this mean for gear in WoW Forever?
With WoW Forever, Blizzard is pursuing an approach where gear does not simply become significantly stronger with each new raid. Instead, the development team relies on so-called horizontal progression.
This means: New items do not necessarily have better stats than older gear. Instead, they may offer special advantages in certain situations.
Several factors play a role here, including:
Enemy types: Certain gear could be especially effective against elementals or other creatures.
Biomes: Different environments are intended to influence which items make sense.
Raid bosses: The optimal gear might vary from boss to boss.
Specialized items: Older or unusual items could also retain long-term usefulness.
Individual playstyle: Players should have more options to tailor their gear to their preferred style of play.
Moon gave an interesting example: In an upcoming raid, there are different zones, including a snowy area and one haunted by ghosts.
Theoretically best gear could therefore already vary within the same raid.
[banner:wow-60-days]
No more BiS lists? It's not that simple
The statement that Blizzard wants to abolish BiS sounds like a huge change at first. In reality, however, it is hardly possible to completely remove Best-in-Slot gear from World of Warcraft.
As long as items have different stats and effects, players will try to find the mathematically best combination.
The crucial difference, however, would be that there might no longer be a single BiS list for all fights.
Instead, players could compile various gear sets, each optimized for specific adversaries or environments.
This would also change the meaning of classic BiS guides. Rather than a general list, several recommendations for different situations could emerge in the future.
Does this make WoW Forever more complicated?
This is exactly where the biggest criticism of Blizzard's ideas lies.
What initially sounds like more freedom could mean additional effort, especially for ambitious raid players.
Those who previously collected a complete BiS set could then mostly focus on the fights themselves.
With the new approach, it may become necessary to own several gear sets at once.
This could have several possible disadvantages:
More items take up additional space in inventory and bank.
Switching gear before individual boss fights might become advisable.
Players would have to engage more intensively with opponents, biomes, and special item effects.
New BiS guides could become even more extensive and complicated.
Especially performance-oriented raid groups might require additional gear sets.
Blizzard is at least aware of the inventory problem. The development team has already announced larger bags and improved item management options.
Whether these measures will be sufficient remains to be seen.
Why the idea still has great potential
Despite the criticism, the new gear philosophy could become one of the most interesting changes in WoW Forever.
In classic WoW versions, many items lose significance as new raids are released. A new item with higher stats often simply replaces the previous one.
With horizontal progression, however, items from older dungeons or raids could remain interesting in the long term.
A trinket that is particularly effective against a certain enemy type could still hold an important place in the gear months later.
This could make the game world more lively. Players would have a reason to revisit older content rather than focusing exclusively on the latest raid.
This could be a decisive advantage, especially for an MMORPG intended to be developed over the long term.
What about the pre-raid BiS lists?
For now, players do not have to do without their familiar gear lists.
Pre-raid BiS guides for various classes and specializations already exist in WoW Forever.
These help prepare for upcoming challenges through dungeons, quests, professions, and reputation rewards.
The first three raids in WoW Forever are scheduled to open on December 9, 2026. By then at the latest, it should become clear how much the new biomes and enemy types actually influence gear choices.
It is also important to note: Blizzard has not announced a complete abolition of all BiS lists so far. Aidan Moon's statements rather describe the design philosophy behind future itemization.
Conclusion: More role-playing or even more min-maxing?
The idea behind Blizzard's plans is quite understandable. World of Warcraft should once again thrive on players making decisions, experimenting, and consciously adapting their gear to specific challenges.
Instead of simply following the next BiS list, creativity and preparation could play a greater role again.
However, there is also the risk that the exact opposite will happen.
Ambitious players will still try to get the maximum out of their characters. If there is a different optimal set for each boss in the future, one BiS list could suddenly become ten.
Therefore, the decisive factor will be how large Blizzard makes the differences between the individual gear sets.
If specialized items offer interesting advantages without being strictly necessary, WoW Forever could indeed allow more player freedom.
If, on the other hand, each raid boss requires fully optimized gear, the new system is likely to cause additional inventory stress.
And that leaves the big question: Does WoW Forever really become more fun without fixed BiS lists, or will the pursuit of perfect gear ultimately become even more complicated?
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first!
Write a comment
You must be logged in to write a comment.